Sunday, May 25, 2008

My picky opinion about using languages

I was teaching in a quiet coffee shop this afternoon, but it wasn't quite anymore since several girls came in speaking English loudly. In the very beginning, I didn't know if they are Taiwanese or not. Yet, after a few minutes, I realized that they are actually Taiwanese because they started to talk in Mandarin. They kept being the most noisy group in the shop. In their conversation, it's about half Mandarin and half English. Among the English part, the most words I heard is "shit". Yes, "shit". It's really uncomfortable hearing that from time to time, especially from girls at the age of 13-15.

It is a very interesting phenomenon in Taiwan: we tend to admire people who speak fluent English. English is one of the subjects in school, but very few people really like English and use it well. That's the reason why people envy those with proficient English ability, especially speaking ability (because you can only know if a person's English is good from his/her speaking ability at first)

Consequently, you can always find people speaking English loudly but not really fluently in public places. Sometimes I call it sort of "show off".

From a very picky perspective, if you want to speak a language, just use it thoroughly. It is reasonable sometimes if you happen to forget how to say a word in your non-native language. But using English WORDS when you speak Chinese?? That's very weird. It shows nothing but how bad both your English and Chinese are. Because you can not say a whole sentence in English, and also not be able to know how to say the ENGLISH WORD in CHINESE. Of course, if you are in English class or having language exchange, that would be a totally different situation. Instead, students who try hard to express themselves are supposed to be encouraged.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

I speak a couple of languages and mix them. Even if it's showing off it's a good idea to let kids use allk the words they can (even swear words)Your English is excellent..you deserve a big kiss and hug for that alone.

Iris said...

hi swimanog,

thanks for you comment. :) I am interested that how many languages do you speak? Cheers!

Iris

Anonymous said...

In countries like Malaysia or Singapore, people often mix their languages as most speak more than one language. It's the culture.

Iris said...

hi cc,

thanks for your comment. I didn't intend to criticize any other places. All I want to say is situation here. Also, I know that people in other places might have different culture and habits, and I won't say anything about that.

Iris

Anonymous said...

No worries, I totally get it. Just wanted to share that info with you. :)